STANDING IN THE MARKET
Carrier selection vetting programs like TIA and others address an important and different question than the one this practice addresses. Understanding the distinction matters, because the two are complementary, not competing, and an organization that confuses them ends up with a gap neither one was designed to close.
SELECTION VERSUS DEFENSE
Selection Framework℠ exist to help an organization choose and qualify carriers well. They establish criteria for what a sound vetting process looks like, and they are valuable references that get cited in industry conversations, audits, and training.
The Case Dismissed℠ Protocol is not a selection Framework℠. It does not tell an organization which carrier to choose. It documents the decision that was made, the data available at the time, and the reasoning behind it, in a form built to survive discovery and depositions rather than to satisfy an internal audit.
Selection Framework℠ get cited. This gets hired, because the question a plaintiff’s attorney asks is not did you follow a recognized framework, but can you prove, with a timestamped record, exactly what your organization knew and did at the moment that matters.


HOW THEY WORK TOGETHER
An organization using carrier selection vetting programs like TIA and others for carrier selection and the Case Dismissed Protocol℠ for documentation and defense is not running two competing systems. It is running a selection Framework℠ and an implementation and defense layer on top of it. The selection Framework℠ answers who you chose and why you believed they were qualified. The Protocol answers what you can prove about the moment you chose them, the moments after, and the moment something went wrong.
Organizations already committed to a selection Framework℠ do not need to abandon it to adopt the Protocol. The two are designed to sit on top of each other.
Company Info
Risk Reward Consulting Inc.
The CEO’s Strategy Challenger℠
Contact Details
Norris Beren
📞 847-514-6767
✉️ [email protected]
Case Dismissed℠, The Shipper/Broker/Carrier Defense Protocol℠, The Assumption Gap℠, The Forensic Vetting Process℠, and The Lawsuit Dismissal Procedure℠ are proprietary frameworks of Risk Reward Consulting Inc. All rights reserved.
© Copyright 2026 Risk Reward Consulting, Inc. All Rights Reserved
