FOR SHIPPERS, BROKERS, & CARRIERS


THE OPERATIONAL REALITY BEHIND THE GOVERNANCE QUESTION

Boards, general counsel, CFOs, and investors are asking what changed after Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II. The answer comes from the operations level: from the people running carrier selection, dispatch, and broker qualification every day. This page is for you.

427x422xcsm schichtarbeit neu 9a7cc06a50.jpg.pagespeed.ic.21ahekveku

SIX OPERATIONS, SIX EXPOSURES

Freight Brokers

28,000 licensed freight brokers in America lost the legal protection they operated under for 50 years on May 15, 2026. The six conventional data points used to vet carriers across the industry were built for a legal environment that no longer exists. The Protocol replaces assumption with a forensic process, built so that when discovery begins, there is nothing for a plaintiff’s attorney to work with.

Shippers and Manufacturers

Hiring the broker does not end a shipper’s exposure. Plaintiff’s attorneys are now asking, in depositions, whether the shipper exercised reasonable care in selecting, qualifying, and monitoring the broker it hired. Most shippers have no documented answer. This is a process problem with no defined procedure until now.

Trucking Companies with Brokerage Authority

A carrier that also holds brokerage authority carries the exposure of both roles. Carrier selection liability and the documentation requirements of the post-Montgomery era apply to the brokerage function regardless of the company’s primary identity or size.

Trucking Executives: A Conversation Worth Having with Your Shipper Customers

Your shipper customers are now sitting inside the same liability chain you are. Most of them do not know it yet. Their boards have not been briefed. Their general counsel has not added it to a risk framework. Their CFOs have not assessed the exposure.

Bringing this conversation to your shipper customers is not a sales call. It is a service. It positions you as an advisor who is watching the landscape on their behalf, not just a capacity provider. And it opens a conversation about governance and risk that very few trucking executives are having with their shipper accounts right now.

If you want to introduce this program to your shipper customers, Norris Beren can support that conversation directly, with materials, briefings, and engagement formats built for a shipper audience.

Transportation Defense Attorneys

The Protocol was built around what plaintiff’s attorneys demand in discovery and what defense attorneys need to counter it: a documented, timestamped record of every carrier selection decision, every data point reviewed, and every action taken at every operational moment. Norris Beren works directly with defense counsel both as a pre-litigation program architect and as a consulting resource once litigation is active.

Insurance Brokers and Insurance Companies

Insurance covers the verdict. The Protocol reduces the likelihood of one. A policyholder operating under the Protocol presents a documented risk profile that exceeds conventional underwriting requirements, which changes the underwriting conversation and the claims outlook. Collaboration and licensing arrangements are available for insurance brokers and carriers who want to bring this to their policyholders.

Associations and Training Organizations

TIA, TCA, NIT-League, CSCMP, ATA, and state and other national trucking and shipper association members are at the center of this ruling’s impact. Association-endorsed, co-branded, and member education versions of the Protocol are available, along with conference presentations and member webinars.

i

THE QUESTIONS BEING ASKED IN DEPOSITIONS RIGHT NOW

For Brokers: Can your team prove it checked a carrier’s CSA scores on the day and time of dispatch, not only at onboarding? If a dispatcher made a carrier selection at 4:30 on a Friday afternoon, what is the documented evidence of that decision? If a plaintiff’s attorney subpoenaed your carrier selection records for the last 90 days, what would they find?
For Shippers: When you hired the broker who would select the carrier for your freight, what documented process did you use to qualify that broker before giving them access to your freight? That is the question now appearing in demand letters.

Company Info

Risk Reward Consulting Inc.
The CEO’s Strategy Challenger℠

Contact Details

Norris Beren
📞 847-514-6767
✉️ [email protected]

Case Dismissed℠, The Shipper/Broker/Carrier Defense Protocol℠, The Assumption Gap℠, The Forensic Vetting Process℠, and The Lawsuit Dismissal Procedure℠ are proprietary frameworks of Risk Reward Consulting Inc. All rights reserved.

© Copyright 2026 Risk Reward Consulting, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top